Saturday, October 31, 2009

Legal Realism Authority

I think that legal realism and Raz make a valid point. I think people recognize and respect legal officials. People follow these laws because they respect the authority of these people. Police men, judges, the President are just few of the legal officials we follow because we respect their authority. We drive slowly on the highways because are aware of the authority that the Police have, we may not agree with these laws follow them because of the respect of the Police. Judges are the same way they are respected people within the courtroom, they have lots of authority and we respect their decisions and follow what they say. For the President we may not agree but we follow his actions, we may not want to go to war but most of us respect and support our troops. As mentioned before there are athletes that are respected enough that they may say something and people will follow. In commercials Michael Jordan is probably the best example he is probably the most respected basketball player so when he advertises his Air Jordan shoes lots of people go out their and buy them. I don’t think this is the best ways for laws to be. I would still go with laws that are based on morals. I think laws are better when people believe in them. The legal realism approach is good though because I think authority has a lot to do with people following the law.

2 comments:

  1. I agree with what you are saying about respect of authority. I believe this has to do more about morals, however, because respect comes from somewhere. A person has respect towards another for some reason, whether it is due to experience, or some aura they put off. This respect comes from morals and discretion from the individual. I also agree with how you said it is better to have a law where the people believe in it morally, but this is very hard to appease to the public as a whole because everyone is different.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with the above comment in that it is very hard to appease everyone when it comes to morals. I think that the strongest sense of respect from legal realism could come if you respected a legal/executive figure not only for their position and rank, but for their morals as well. Even if the law is not completley alligned with your morals, if there is an authority figure that you respect and who has similar morals to you, something that he/she represents or backs would have much more meaning to you and I feel as though people would be much more willing to support the given legislation.

    ReplyDelete