Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Accepting law

As Raz says, accepting the law on the authority that it must be obeyed is the basis for obedience in western cultures. This poses a very large problem to our society. Simply accepting that the law is the law and that is the merits that it should be followed on is dangerous. The first example that comes to mind when this method of authority is mentioned is Nazi Germany. When we look at the political and social environment at the time, we see that there is a subtle upbringing of new laws that would seem ghastly by any comparison. Since Germany was in a political climate that fostered its citizens to be desperate, they accepted laws that were simply placed upon them and obeyed because they were simply laws of authority. It is hard to believe that the laws that the people of Germany under the Nazi regime were accepted at all. There is clearly no way that these laws could have been accepted on the basis of morals. Small groups of Germans may have agreed with these morals, but the entire society submitted to this rule. It is highly unlikely that they would all submit to these laws on a moral basis. This is one of the largest problems with submitting to laws only on the basis of authority. It is easier to be convinced to obey immoral laws simply because they are law.

3 comments:

  1. I agree. I believe that the sole reason people follow laws is based on the concept of obedience. WWII is a perfect example of it because almost no one during that time agreed with what was going on morally. They followed because they were afraid of the consequences.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that it is dangerous to accept law simply because it is the law and has been proclaimed by an authority figure. The masses get in the mindset of following orders and most people will follow almost any rule, if given to them by an authority figure. But if the masses were to question and fight every single law, then congress would be at a standstill and nothing would ever get done. The most that people can do is trust that they have elected the right people to make just laws and then vote on the laws that the elected officials propose. “I was just following orders” is a disgusting excuse. People should know basic right from wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think it's important to follow orders, but it's also important to know WHY you're following those orders. Like Lorne said, "just following orders" is a horrible excuse for doing something wrong. It is necessary to know why laws are intact. Then, if you disagree with the laws, you can work at amending them.

    ReplyDelete