Saturday, July 25, 2009

Henry Gates

In response to Mike’s post about Henry Gates and his question of ‘is police bias an increasing predicament that needs more focus?’ After taking several classes regarding this subject I do feel that racial profiling is a major problem in our country. However, the incident involving Henry Gates is not one of these cases. Sgt. Crowley received a call about a burglary in progress, was given a description of the individuals and arrived to find one of the individuals inside the home. He then ordered the individual (Gates) to come outside and provide him with identification at which time Gates began to argue that he was a victim of racial profiling at this point. The argument continued to the point where Sgt. Crowley issued a summary citation for disorderly conduct. Although Gates’ actions did fall under the offense of disorderly conduct, given the circumstances Sgt. Crowley probably would have been better off not issuing the citation (which was later dropped). With regard to the racial profiling aspect, I do not believe the police did anything wrong in this instance. Race was used purely as a descriptor, not a predictor which is how police should view any possible crime involving race.

1 comment:

  1. You point out a number of valid points, and I will admit I did jump the gun when reading this case because of the emotion regarding the whole circumstance. It is an infuriating subject to talk about. Take for instance this past week. A Boston police officer calling Henry Gates a “jungle monkey” at a press conference (see link below). I do not want to make this issue a race topic; however, I do want to make an overall assumption that the police have bias judgments when dealing with society. This is an issue we have to address because it affects the future of our citizens within the Justice System. This case may not have to do with that problem, but it definitely brings light to it.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ylK11FxxLCw

    ReplyDelete